31 Aug 04
Oozing ConfidenceAlberto Savoia writes:
A few months ago, on April 1(!) 2004 to be precise, I posted an article on eXtreme Feedback. The article was on a relatively serious subject: "How do you get your team to pay attention to the software/project status and metrics that you care about?", but one of my solutions for getting the team to pay attention was to "invent" and implement eXtreme Feedback Devices (XFDs) that would be very visible, fun, and hard to ignore.
One of these XFDs consists of a pair of lava lamps (one green and one red) remotely connected to our build and test system in such a way that a successful build (all tests pass) turns on the green lava lamp, and a failed build (or failed tests) turns on the red one.
The original Java lava lamps have been glowing red and green for the past several months in our offices, and have achieved something of a cult status (e.g. they are included in Mike Clark’s excellent book Pragmatic Project Automation, and have recently received a fair amount of buzz on Slashdot).
The interesting thing, for me, is that something that I started as something of a joke (it was April 1st after all) actually turned out to be a very useful tool in more ways than one. Sure, I could go to our CruiseControl page to see if they build is broken, or set-up email alerts, but keeping track of the lamps (which are centrally located in our development area) is easier, faster, and gives me an ongoing view into the current status and ebb-and-flow of our build and test cycles.
I got an opportunity to visit Alberto’s project a few weeks back and witness first-hand those infamous lava lamps. You really can’t miss them. When I walked in, the red lamp was bubbling. And yet the managers weren’t beating the programmers about the head and shoulders, as some might fear. Indeed, I didn’t sense any sort of panic or condescension. What I did sense was confidence.
See, the team had learned to take the red lamp as feedback. They run an extensive battery of tests on every build and the red lamp was telling them that their tests were actually testing something. An assertion somewhere had failed the last time somebody checked in code. This is a good thing. Indeed, this is what continuous integration is all about. It becomes a bad thing when the green lamp never turns on. So they were diligently (and confidently) working to repair the build as a priority over other tasks for the day because they didn’t want to work on unstable ground.
It’s important to note that Alberto’s team is a bright group of folks building impressive products. Feedback is serious business, but they’ve found a way to make it fun. They use the lava lamps to their advantage, not as gimmicks or another way for the pointy-haired manager to keep tabs on their work. And when the lamp does go red, they’re confident that it won’t stay that way for long.